I finished Alice Feiring’s book today — it was like a split of a great wine (meaning a 375 ml bottle) — not nearly enough of a good thing and left me wanting more…..
I think it is an important book that deserves attention and discussion. I know it will stir emotions, but hope that it will also generate discussion and an desire for wine drinkers to know what it is they are drinking.
Wineries are not required to disclose all of the elements in the wine or the process to make the wine. That nice little bottle of wine you brought home could have been manipulated with designer yeasts, enzymes, tannin, oak chips, oak on a rope, through the bunghole oak socks, oak dust, acid, beet juice and other additives — not to metion the over-extracting techniques, micro-oxygenation, dialysis and reverse osmosis — and a whole list of things you might not want to know about. When did wine become a vinicultural hot dog?
Too strange to be true? View this article in Wines & Vines, a publication aimed at winemakers, that details all kinds of bells and whistles to add to your winemaking bag of tricks. The article is appropriately entitled Viagra for Barrels. Insert bad joke here.
Wine making began as art, evolved to become a combination of art and science. Today, it is often more driven by science and technology, rather than being the result of a process that for the most part occurs in the vineyard. Add to the mix that the market is heavily influenced by the opinions of a select few critics (especially Parker) who award very ripe, fruit-driven, with heavy oak — and winemakers take every tool of the trade to manipulate the results, leaving out authenticity, place, artistry and tradition.
A difficult pill to swallow for those of us that love to ponder the aromatics and the complexities and nuances of a wine’s flavor profile. Having spent time, energy and money on something on much that was at least in part an illusion….and now you are stuck with a few cases of that 1982 Marion Jones Estate Cabernet bottled under the supervision of Frau Blücher.
The good news is that there are still some gems that are wonders of nature and artistry — and those are the wines Alice Feiring champions — they are at least worthy of your consideration. At the end of the day, you can let your palate decide — but you should know what you are drinking.
In general, I tend to agree with many of the points that she makes in the book. At the same time, I am sure there are some wines that I might enjoy that she might turn her nose up at — but that is also my prerogative. One’s taste in wine is in large part subjective, but I certainly think there are some points that many of us can agree on.
Her book is one of the most enjoyable I have read about wine in a few years. Most of all, it will make you wonder just exactly is in that bottle and how did it get there — a question that is much more difficult to answer than it should be. Strongly recommended.
Posted in Reference | Tagged Alice Feiring, Natural Wine, The Battle for Wine and Love, wine and technology, wine books | No Comments »






You could also serve Mas de Bressades Viognier/Roussane blend as well. But it’s spring — and for me, the release of the latest vintage of rosé wines is always one of the best rites of spring.






